Classic and Classy Motorcycles Ltd

1990s Harley‑Davidson Sportster 1200 Valuation Report

Date: August 2025

Historical Overview

The 1990s Sportster 1200 (XL1200) featured the Evolution engine paired with a 5-speed gearbox and classic Sportster styling. Known for its durability and custom potential, it remains popular in the UK for both riders and collectors.

Valuation Analysis

Real UK listings and auction values provide the following price brackets:

• Project Condition: Typically £3,000–£4,000
  Non-running or needing significant recommissioning. Auction estimates ranged around £2,500–£3,500 for spares/repair examples. (Auction Listing)
• Roadworthy Condition: £4,500–£6,000
  Registered, mechanically sound bikes with average miles. A 1989 XLH883 sold at UK auction for £4,725, indicating similar pricing for 1200cc models. (Auction Result)
• Restored / Excellent Condition: £6,000–£8,000+
  Low mileage or restored examples with clean documentation. UK classifieds list early Sportster 1200s in this bracket. (UK Listings)

Factors Affecting Value

• Service & Documentation: Full V5C, MOT history, and EVO engine maintenance records reassure buyers.
• Originality vs Upgrades: Factory gear indicator, peanut tank, authentic exhausts and accessories preserve classic appeal. Excessive modification may reduce collectible value.
• Matching Numbers: Original engine and frame combinations are preferred by collectors and command higher prices.

Conclusion

The 1990s Sportster 1200 remains a practical and classic choice with steady UK demand. Even running-but-basic examples reliably fetch £4,000–£6,000. Finely restored bikes with provenance can exceed £7,000. Values hold well across auction and private sale channels thanks to the bike’s strong heritage and ease of upkeep.

All Valuations